How to Make Yogurt in a Bread Machine
You can make yogurt in a bread machine only if your model has a yogurt program that holds 95 to 115°F for 6 to 12 hours. Warm milk plus live culture, keep the lid closed, chill after culturing, and do not use a standard bread cycle.
On this page (12 sections)
- Does your bread machine have a yogurt program?
- What bread machine yogurt recipe works best?
- How do you make yogurt step by step in a bread machine?
- Why does temperature matter so much for yogurt?
- Can you use a bread machine without a yogurt setting?
- Which bread machines suit a yogurt attempt?
- How do you thicken homemade yogurt?
- How do you store and use the yogurt?
- What went wrong with my yogurt?
- How to Make Yogurt in a Bread Machine: 7 Mistakes to Avoid
- How do you clean a bread machine after yogurt?
- Which setup should you buy for yogurt and bread?
You can make yogurt in a bread machine only if your model has a yogurt program that holds 95 to 115°F for 6 to 12 hours. Warm milk plus live culture, keep the lid closed, chill after culturing, and do not use a standard bread cycle.
A bread machine yogurt recipe is simple in steps and strict in conditions. Milk, culture, steady warmth, time, and cold storage do the work, with no kneading or baking involved.
Does your bread machine have a yogurt program?
Check for a labeled yogurt setting before you buy milk or starter. The setting should hold a low temperature for hours, not bake, rise dough, or jam fruit.
Many bread machines offer bread, dough, gluten-free, cake, and jam cycles, but those cycles do not equal yogurt. A jam cycle heats and stirs, and a dough cycle warms only briefly.
Read the manual for the exact yogurt program, time range, and milk amount.
If your model lacks that program, you can still use the machine for other foods. Our guide to What Else Can You Make In A Bread Maker Besides Bread? covers those options.
What bread machine yogurt recipe works best?
Use 1 quart of whole or 2% milk plus 1 to 2 tablespoons of plain yogurt with live active cultures. That simple mix gives the bacteria food and a head start.
Whole milk makes a thicker, richer yogurt. Lower-fat milk works too, but the result will be thinner and may need longer draining.
Avoid milk with added thickeners if you want to judge the culture on its own.
Warm the milk gently to 110°F, then cool it to 100 to 110°F before adding the starter. Too hot can kill the culture, and too cool can slow it.
A thermometer helps more than guesswork here.
How do you make yogurt step by step in a bread machine?
Warm, inoculate, set the yogurt program, wait 6 to 12 hours, then chill. Keep the pan stable and the lid closed for the full culturing time.
- Clean the bread pan and any yogurt jars or lids with hot, soapy water, then rinse well.
- Heat the milk to 110°F in a saucepan or microwave-safe container.
- Let it cool to 100 to 110°F, then whisk in the starter yogurt.
- Pour the mix into the bread pan or into clean heat-safe jars set in the pan.
- Select the yogurt program, close the lid, and leave it undisturbed.
- When the program ends, cover and chill for at least 4 hours.
- Taste, thicken by draining if you like, and refrigerate the rest.
Do not stir, lift the lid, or move the pan during culturing. Movement and temperature drops can delay setting.
Chill before you judge texture, because warm yogurt always looks thinner than it will after cooling.
Why does temperature matter so much for yogurt?
Yogurt bacteria need steady warmth, usually 95 to 115°F, to turn lactose into lactic acid. That acid thickens the milk and gives yogurt its tang.
A bread machine thermostat that swings from cool to baking heat will not work. The yogurt program should stay in a narrow band for the full cycle.
If your manual lists no yogurt temperature or time, do not assume another setting will match.
Heat also matters before culturing. Milk heated to 110°F helps wake the culture, but milk above 120°F can damage it.
Stir the starter in only after the milk cools to a safe range.
Can you use a bread machine without a yogurt setting?
No, do not try to force yogurt on a bread, dough, or keep-warm cycle. Those cycles do not hold 95 to 115°F for 6 to 12 hours.
Some cooks set a dough cycle and check the pan often. That approach risks overheating during a heating element cycle and cooling during a rest period.
The batch may stay liquid, smell off, or grow unwanted bacteria.
If your machine lacks a yogurt program, use a yogurt maker, an oven with a reliable low setting, or a cooler with warm water. Save the bread machine for bread, dough, and other cycles it was built to run.
Which bread machines suit a yogurt attempt?
Choose a model with a true yogurt program, a removable pan, and clear temperature control. Those three traits matter more than loaf size or crust options for this task.
The West Bend Hi-Rise Bread Maker Machine Programmable is a 3-lb machine with 12 programs, 3 loaf sizes, and 3 crust colors. Its horizontal pan and dual knead blades suit dough and bread work, and the maker lists gluten-free among its settings.

A 3-lb programmable bread maker with 12 settings for bread and dough jobs, so check its manual for a yogurt program before you use it for yogurt.
See it on AmazonWest Bend says the pan holds 2 lb, 2.5 lb, or 3 lb loaves, and the machine includes knead blades, a measuring cup and spoon, and a blade removal tool. That size helps with bread batches, but it does not prove the machine can hold yogurt temperature.
The Amazon Basics Programmable Bread Maker is a 2-lb machine with 14 settings, ExpressBake, and 3 crust options. Amazon Basics says its settings cover breads, doughs, gluten-free options, and jams.
That list does not include yogurt in the details we checked.

A compact 2-lb programmable machine with 14 settings for bread, dough, and jam, so confirm a yogurt program in the manual before you try this bread machine yogurt recipe.
See it on AmazonFor toast after yogurt and bread, the bella 4 Slice Slim Toaster has two 10-inch slots and 6 shade settings. It fits thick slices and long bread, but it plays no role in culturing yogurt.

A slim 4-slice toaster with long slots for serving toast alongside homemade bread and yogurt.
See it on AmazonHow do you thicken homemade yogurt?
Chill first, then drain the yogurt in cheesecloth or a fine strainer for 30 minutes to 2 hours. That step removes whey and gives you a thicker texture without additives.
Save the whey if you want it for smoothies or baking. Stir the drained yogurt gently until smooth, because hard stirring can loosen the set.
Season it after draining, with fruit, honey, or herbs.
If you want Greek-style yogurt, use more milk and a longer drain. If you want drinkable yogurt, skip draining and thin it with a little milk after chilling.
How do you store and use the yogurt?
Refrigerate yogurt within 2 hours of culturing and use it within 5 to 7 days. Keep the container covered and avoid dipping a used spoon into the batch.
Homemade yogurt freezes poorly because ice crystals break the texture. Use it in sauces, dressings, marinades, smoothies, and baking within the week.
For breakfast, serve it with sliced bread, granola, or fruit.
Keep a small amount of plain yogurt as starter for the next batch. Use it within a few days, and discard it if it smells sour beyond normal tang or shows mold.
What went wrong with my yogurt?
Check temperature, culture age, milk type, and lid opening first. Those four causes explain most failed batches.
Milk that was too hot can kill the culture and leave the batch liquid. Old starter can work slowly or not at all, so use fresh plain yogurt with live cultures.
Opening the lid lets heat escape and can delay setting.
If the yogurt is tangy but thin, it may need more chilling or draining. If it smells sharp, bitter, or yeasty, discard it.
Do not taste questionable dairy to test it.
How to Make Yogurt in a Bread Machine: 7 Mistakes to Avoid
Use the yogurt program, fresh culture, correct temperature, and a closed lid every time. Small shortcuts cause most failures with a bread machine yogurt recipe.
- Using a bread or dough cycle instead of a yogurt program.
- Adding starter to milk that is still above 120°F.
- Opening the lid to check progress during culturing.
- Using flavored yogurt or yogurt without live cultures as starter.
- Skipping the chilling step before you judge texture.
- Moving the pan or pressing buttons mid-cycle.
- Tasting or serving yogurt that smells off or shows mold.
Learn the related cycles before you experiment. Our post on What Is The Jam Setting On A Bread Maker? explains why that hot, stirring cycle is wrong for yogurt.
Our guide to What Is The Cake Mode On A Bread Maker? shows the same point for baking cycles.
How do you clean a bread machine after yogurt?
Wash the pan with warm, soapy water right after chilling and dry it fully. Yogurt residue can sour fast in a warm kitchen.
Do not soak the bread pan longer than the manual allows. Remove any knead blade if your model has one, and dry the pan so water spots do not form.
Wipe the interior cavity with a damp cloth and dry it before you close the lid.
For general bread use, start with How to Make Bread in a Bread Machine? and What Is a Bread Machine? if you are new to the appliance. Those guides cover loading, cycles, and basic care.
Which setup should you buy for yogurt and bread?
Pick the machine with a verified yogurt program first, then loaf size and crust control. Yogurt success depends on that program, not on extra bread settings.
If you already own a bread machine, check the manual for a yogurt cycle with time and temperature details. If it has one, use the recipe above.
If it does not, buy a dedicated yogurt maker or use another slow-warming method.
For bread alone, the West Bend model suits larger 3-lb batches, while the Amazon Basics model suits smaller 2-lb batches and faster ExpressBake cycles. Neither claim replaces a manual check for yogurt.
The bella toaster is a serving-side pick for toast, not a culturing tool. Keep your budget focused on the machine that can hold yogurt temperature, because that is the part your bread machine yogurt recipe cannot fake.
Frequently asked questions
Can every bread machine make yogurt?
No, only models with a dedicated yogurt program that holds a low, steady temperature for several hours can make yogurt reliably. A bread, dough, or keep-warm cycle does not hold the right range, so check your manual for a yogurt setting before you start.
What temperature should a bread machine use for yogurt?
Most yogurt cultures need 95 to 115°F, with 100 to 110°F working for many starter cultures. Your machine should hold that range without cycling to baking heat, and you should confirm the setting in the manual or on the control panel.
How long does yogurt take in a bread machine?
Plan on 6 to 12 hours of culturing, depending on the culture and how tangy you want the yogurt. After culturing, chill the yogurt for at least 4 hours before you stir, drain, or serve it.
Why is my bread machine yogurt runny?
Runny yogurt often comes from milk that was too hot, a weak or old culture, or opening the lid during culturing. It can also come from a machine that does not hold a steady low temperature, so check the program and starter before you repeat the batch.
About this guide: Our look at bread machine yogurt recipe draws on maker specs, materials and what owners report. See how we research.



